Here's a demo comparing database articles on Socrates to Seinfeld and Platonic bomber Steven Kayevitch.

Dr. G's Sample Library Assignment #2
(assigned in Lesson 6)

Gary Gutchess (student)
Dr. G. Gutchess (instructor)
English 101
11 Sept. 2003

What is the influence of Socrates today?

Journalist Bettijane Levine reports on the rise of philosophy in a current popular culture wave of American courses, forums, counseling, and self-help books. She mentions that an American Philosophical Practitioners' Association has been formed by Lou Marinoff, author of Plato not Prosac: Applying Eternal Wisdom to Everyday Problems. Levine also describes the philosophically-oriented corporate consulting practice of Tom Morris, author of If Aristotle Ran General Motors. She refers to another book (but does not provide the title) by Prof. William Irwin, a textbook used in college philosophy courses that study TV shows like Seinfeld and The Simpsons. She notes that NPR has begun a program called "Philosophy Talk" hosted by Kenneth Taylor and John Parry.

Although Socrates is the key figure in this popular philosophy movement, Levine does not appear to know much about him. She mistakes his historical date as "about 500 B.C." Her article is sketchy, and her sources of information are biased in that they are selling philosophy to the public--or trying to sell it. Yet it's clear that the article does have research value because Levine has done some leg work to identify a variety of sources that could help to answer the research question: what is Socrates' influence today? In particular she mentions three possibly helpful books by current or former philosophy professors.

Comparing Levine's article with Ron Grossman's story on Platonic bomber Steven Kayevitch, both have limited research value because they are simply entertainment-section newspaper articles produced under journalistic time and space constraints. Yet Levine's article is much more useful than Grossman's, research-wise, because it proves more leads for researchers to follow. Where Grossman's story is purely anecdotal in refering to Kayevitch's book, Levine mentions at least three books, a trade association and a radio program, some or all of which may be good sources of information. Levine's article also provides search terms by giving the names of seven current or former professors who are attempting to popularize Plato.

<page break>

WORKS CITED

Grossman, Ron. "The Remarkable Tale of a Priest Turned Terrorist Turned Philosopher." Chicago Tribune 10 Jul. 2003: 1. ProQuest. Tompkins Cortland Coll. Lib. 11 Sep. 2003 <http://gateway.proquest.com/>

Levine, Bettijane. "From Socrates to Seinfeld: The rise of practical philosophy." Chicago Tribune 30 Sep. 2003: 1. InfoTrac. Tompkins Cortland Coll. Lib. 10 Oct. 2003 <http://infotrac.galegroup.com/>

return to Library Assignment #2