ENGLISH 101.  ACADEMIC WRITING
Dr. G's Plato Exam Score Sheet


STUDENT NAME:

CONTENT                              0       1        2        3        4        5

ORGANIZATION                  0       1        2        3        4        5  

WRITING                               0       1        2        3        4        5

WHOLE COW (add above) =              

GRADE (WHOLE COW divided by 3) =               

SCORING KEY (take highest applicable score in each category)

                     CONTENT:
                     5. cites from all four of Plato's dialogues; includes at least seven citations; 
                         shows no citation errors (including Works Cited errors)
                         shows no misquotes, misstatements or misapplications of sources.
                     4. cites from at least three dialogues; includes at least six citations.
                         shows no more than one citation error (including Works Cited errors)
                         shows up to one misquote, misstatement or misapplications of sources
                     3. cites from at least three of dialogues; includes at least five citations.
                         shows no more than two citation errors (including Works Cited errors)
                         shows up to one misquote, misstatement or misapplications of sources.
                     2. cites from at least two dialogues; includes at least four citations.
                         shows more than two citation errors (including Works Cited errors)
                         shows up to two misquotes, misstatements or misapplications of sources
                     1. cites from less than two dialogues or includes less than four citations,
                         or shows more than three citation errors (including Works Cited errors)
                         or shows more than two misquotes/misstatements/misapplications 

                      ORGANIZATION:
                      5. has all five: intro paragraph with thesis sentence; well organized body of
                          evidence, coherent conclusion, coherence of paper with thesis,
                          MLA manuscript format
                      4. has four of five elements reasonably well executed 
                      3. has three of five elements reasonably well executed
                      2. has two of five elements
                      1. has one of five elements
                          
                       WRITING:
                       5. two or fewer errors in grammar, punctuation, spelling, and usage
                       4. three to four errors in grammar, punctuation, spelling, and usage
                       3. five to six errors in grammar, punctuation, spelling, and usage
                       2. seven to eight errors in grammar, punctuation, spelling, and usage
                       1. more than eight errors in grammar, punctuation, spelling, and usage